Decision-Making Through the Lens of Regret
By Greg & Lynn McDonald
The advantage of age is a beautiful thing and a gift, even in a society obsessed with youth. By the time you reach our stage of life, you’ve made your share of poor decisions—some you regret deeply. While we could share a list of our successes, and there have been many, the reality is our greatest lessons have come from our mistakes, not our triumphs. With age, we may lose a bit of speed, but we gain knowledge, wisdom, and perspective that only time and experience can provide.
In our mid-20s, we both chose to follow Jesus. The journey is a long, beautiful story of how God used family, friends, neighbors, and even a realtor to draw us closer to His Son. After the miscarriage of our first child, God planted a seed of curiosity in our hearts and nurtured it through the love and care of those around us. They shared how we were made in God’s image, how He loved us and was crazy about us, and how He sent His Son, Jesus, as a sacrifice so we could have a relationship with the God of the universe.
We realize this is a very different story from what many of our LGBTQ+ children hear when they’re told God hates them and they’re going to hell. We were fortunate to have several remarkable couples pour into our lives and mentor us as we began our walk as Jesus followers.
I (Greg) quickly became the young man who seemed to have an answer for each of life’s challenges, often quoting chapter and verse from my NIV Study Bible. Looking back, I realize how unattractive and unapproachable that made me. I surely alienated many people who were different from me. When we learned our son, Greg Jr., was gay, I responded in ways I instantly knew I would regret. Hurtful words like, “Your life as you know it is over, and we need to get you fixed,” escaped my mouth. As you well know, when we treat others in ways Jesus never would, regret is inevitable. I’d give anything to take those words back.
Our decision to debate the Bible with our son only served to drive him and his friends away—from us and from anything related to church. We were more focused on being right than on being right with God. Ultimately, what we truly wanted was a relationship with Greg Jr. and the ability to be a positive influence in his life. But because we were not safe for him, we lost both our relationship and our influence.
Eventually, we realized that, although we considered ourselves good Christians, we were doing a poor job of imitating Jesus. When this became clear, we humbly asked Greg Jr. for forgiveness. Staying true to form, Greg Jr. was grace-filled—far more than we had been—and he slowly allowed us back into his life. This was a pivotal moment for us. We became determined to avoid future regret by asking ourselves, “If I do or say this, will I later regret my actions?”
In our ministry, we meet many parents who, like us, are well-intentioned but miss the mark, sometimes pushing their children away from Jesus rather than drawing them closer. When facing difficult situations, it’s crucial to pause and consider the long-term implications of our choices. Suzy Welch, a business journalist, author, and former editor-in-chief of the Harvard Business Review, developed the 10-10-10 rule for minimizing regret in her book titled: 10-10-10: A Life Transforming Idea. It involves asking yourself three questions:
How will I feel about this in 10 minutes?
How will I feel about this in 10 months?
How will I feel about this in 10 years?
Often, the things we stress over—like mispronouncing a simple word or forgetting someone's name—won’t matter in 10 minutes. By contrast, things we neglect, such as our health, finances, or not spending time with loved ones, may matter a great deal in 10 months. Even more so, some decisions—like forcing your child to leave home or not attending a wedding—can leave lasting scars and deep regret 10 years down the road, effectively writing yourself out of your child's life.
When making important decisions, we often filter them through the lens of perfection. But perfection is a myth. This can be difficult to recognize, especially if our circle of friends appears nearly flawless. Jesus isn’t asking us to be perfect. He calls us to follow Him and meet people where they are—not where we want them to be. That means loving the people God puts in our path just as Jesus loves us: unconditionally. In other words, the way we love God should be reflected in how we love others, beginning with our children.
Every choice has trade-offs. Choosing one path means missing out on another, and each option brings its own challenges, risks, and disappointments. Making decisions through the lens of regret can help you prioritize maintaining influence in your child’s life. Remember, it may feel like there is a “period” in your child’s story, but (like yours) it’s just a “comma.” Our stories are still being written.

Comments